Catholics, Convicts, and Contract Talent: Jay Harrington on Staffing for a Flexible Future

Today on Legal Late Night, we go from the gridiron of Notre Dame to the front lines of the legal gig economy with Jay Harrington of Latitude Legal. We’re breaking down the math of client loyalty and exploring how law firms can use “elastic capacity” to survive the staff-up struggle without losing their minds (or their profit margins).

Jay Harrington
Listening ON:
Table of Contents
Key Takeaways
  • The Referability Reality Check: Your law firm is a brand, and your Net Promoter Score (NPS) is the only metric that tells you if that brand is thriving or surviving on life support.
  • Elastic Capacity is the New Black: Flexible legal talent—high-level contract attorneys—is becoming a permanent part of the “talent stack” for firms needing to scale without the risk of permanent headcount.
  • Onboarding is Make-or-Break: The secret to a successful “gig” engagement isn’t just the paycheck; it’s having a clear scope of work and a guaranteed hour count ready to go on day one.

NPS: Do Your Clients Like You More Than Spirit Airlines?

We kick things off with a sobering monologue on the Net Promoter Score (NPS). In the legal world, there is often a massive disconnect between how a firm thinks it’s performing and how the client actually feels. NPS is the bridge over that gap, derived from one simple question: How likely are you to refer us on a scale of 1 to 10?

Promoters (9-10) are your raving fans; Passives (7-8) are the silent majority; and Detractors (1-6) are actively sinking your ship. According to the Clio Legal Trends Report, the average NPS for law firms sits at a measly 25—right alongside wireless carriers and airlines. If you want your firm to be viewed more like Netflix (NPS 41) and less like a budget airline, you have to start by asking the question and acting on the data.

From Skadden to the Shingle: The Evolution of Jay Harrington

Our guest, Jay Harrington, join us with a career path that sounds like a legal thriller. A Michigan Law grad and son of an FBI agent, Jay cut his teeth at Skadden Arps, starting just days after 9/11. He pivoted into bankruptcy law just in time for the 2009 financial crisis, eventually hanging his own shingle in Detroit during the GM and Chrysler restructuring era.

After a decade-plus run in legal consulting and coaching, Jay made the jump to Latitude Legal. The move represents a shift in how the legal industry views “contract work.” What used to be seen as a “bridge for people who couldn’t get real jobs” has evolved into a high-octane marketplace for specialized, big-law-caliber talent seeking autonomy.

Staffing in the Gig Economy: The Latitude Advantage

At Latitude Legal, Jay and his team are seeing a surge in demand for flexible legal talent. Whether it’s covering a leave of absence, managing a nine-month strategic project, or integrating AI without committing to permanent hires, law firms and in-house teams are looking for “elastic capacity.”

Why Lawyers Are Choosing “Flex”

  • Autonomy: Candidates are dictating their terms—working 20 hours a week to write a book or taking a month off between major engagements to recharge.
  • The “Bridge” Effect: It serves as a low-risk testing ground for both the firm and the attorney before committing to a full-time W2 role.
  • Expertise without Overhead: Firms can access “on-demand” specialists in areas like commercial contracts or complex litigation without the weight of a $300k salary and benefits package.

The Counter Program: Jay and the “Harring Tones”

In a segment that may haunt Jay’s three daughters for years, we subjected our guest to “Jay and the Harring Tones.” The game was simple: Jared reads the lyrics, Jay completes the line.

While Jay nailed the “Stairway to Heaven” finish (a staple of middle school dances in the ’80s), he hit a snag with Dr. Dre’s “Bitches Ain’t Shit”—proving that even a Michigan Law degree can’t help you decode every ’90s rap verse. He salvaged his dignity with a last-minute save on Eric Church’s “Springsteen”.

Ready to staff up without the stress? Connect with Latitude Legal today. Be sure to visit Legal Broadcasting Company often for our latest podcasts. If your law firm needs a “perfect reset,” contact Red Cave Law Firm Consulting.

FAQ

Anything above the industry average of 25 is a start, but top-tier service providers should aim for 40+. If your score is negative, it’s time for a total cultural overhaul.

Communication is everything. Have your IT systems ready, provide a clear job description (e.g., “marketing-related MSAs” vs. just “contracts”), and ensure there is billable work waiting for them the moment they log in.

Absolutely not. Latitude focuses on high-level, specialized expertise—think former Big Law partners and in-house counsel handling sophisticated corporate and litigation matters.

Jared Correia headshot photo

Jared Correia, Esq.

Jared D. Correia, Esq. Founder, CEO at Red Cave Law Firm Consulting is a former practicing lawyer, who has been a business management consultant, exclusively for law firms, since 2008. In that time, Correia has worked with 1000s of law firms, all over the world, ranging in size from solo offices to Big Law firms.  He is an internationally recognized legal technology expert. Correia is the founder and CEO of Red Cave Law Firm Consulting, which offers services directly to lawyers, as well as through bar associations, for member attorneys. Correia was the host of the ‘Legal Toolkit’ podcast on Legal Talk Network, from 2009 to 2025. He is currently the host of the ‘Legal Late Night’ podcast on the Legal Broadcasting Company, and the host of the ‘Adventures in LegalTech’ podcast for Above the Law, in addition to contributing to the ATL Tech Center 2025. Correia is a regular presenter for legal organizations, and writes often for law firm business management publications.

Thanks to Our Sponsors

Subscribe TO Our Newsletter

Stay Up-to-Date on Your Favorite Podcasts

Legal Broadcasting Company Logo
The Legal Broadcasting Company (LBC) is where the legal world goes to be heard. We’re a podcast network and media production company built specifically for legal professionals and the audiences they serve.
Podcasts
Good lawyers stay curious. These are the shows that keep them sharp. Start browsing below.

Address

425 Greenwood St., Evanston, IL